Buckeye Peanut Butter Cookies

My sister brought a tin of buckeye cookies to Thanksgiving one year and I ate so many I barely had room for pie, which is saying something because pie is my love language. The next morning I called her at eight o'clock demanding the recipe, and she laughed and said it was embarrassingly easy. She was right, and now I make them every December without fail, usually while listening to the same Chet Baker album on repeat.

The first batch I ever made on my own was a February evening when I was homesick and needed something to do with my hands. Rolling those little peanut butter balls while the rain hit the window felt oddly meditative, and by the time the chocolate was melted I was in a significantly better mood than when I started.

Ingredients

• 1 1/2 cups creamy peanut butter: Skip the natural kind here, the stirny separated stuff, because it makes the filling too oily and the balls wont hold together properly.
• 1/2 cup (113 g) unsalted butter, softened: Pull it out of the fridge an hour ahead so it blends seamlessly with the peanut butter.
• 1 teaspoon vanilla extract: A small amount but it rounds out the sweetness and gives the filling a more rounded, candylike depth.
• 1/2 teaspoon salt: Essential for balancing all that sugar, especially if your peanut butter is on the sweeter side.
• 3 to 4 cups powdered sugar: Start with three and add more gradually until the dough feels like firm playdough that doesnt stick to your palms.
• 2 cups (340 g) semisweet chocolate chips: Ghirardelli or Guittard melt smoother than most grocery store brands, and the coating will have a nicer snap when set.
• 2 tablespoons shortening or coconut oil: This thins the chocolate just enough for dipping and gives the coating a glossy finish instead of a dull one.

Instructions

Make the peanut butter filling:

Beat the peanut butter, softened butter, vanilla, and salt together in a large bowl until the mixture is completely smooth and slightly lighter in color, about two minutes of enthusiastic mixing.

Add the powdered sugar gradually:

Tip in the powdered sugar one cup at a time, mixing well after each addition, and stop when the dough is stiff enough to hold its shape when you squeeze a small handful.

Roll into balls:

Scoop out tablespoon sized portions and roll them between your palms until perfectly round, placing each one on a parchment lined baking sheet as you go.

Chill the balls:

Slide the whole baking sheet into the refrigerator for thirty minutes so the peanut butter firms up and wont fall apart during dipping.

Melt the chocolate:

Combine the chocolate chips and shortening in a microwave safe bowl and heat in thirty second bursts, stirring between each one, until the mixture is silky and completely smooth.

Dip each buckeye:

Poke a toothpick into the top of a chilled peanut butter ball, lower it into the melted chocolate leaving the top third bare, and gently swirl off the excess before setting it back on the parchment.

Set and finish:

Refrigerate the dipped cookies for fifteen to twenty minutes until the chocolate shell is firm, then remove the toothpicks and press down gently on the little holes to smooth them over if you like a cleaner look.

Save to Pinterest

I packed a box of these for a road trip to visit my parents once and they did not survive past the first rest stop, which I consider a compliment to the recipe rather than a failure of my self control.

Choosing the Right Peanut Butter

Conventional creamy peanut butter like Jif or Skippy works best here because it has stabilizers that keep the texture consistent and predictable. Natural peanut butter can work in a pinch, but you need to drain off any excess oil and be prepared to add significantly more powdered sugar to compensate for the softer, wetter texture.

Getting the Chocolate Coating Right

The shortening or coconut oil is not optional, no matter how much you might be tempted to skip it, because straight melted chocolate is too thick and will pull the peanut butter filling off the ball rather than coat it cleanly. You want the consistency of heavy cream, thick enough to cling but thin enough to drip off in a smooth ribbon.

Storing and Sharing Them

These keep beautifully in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to two weeks and actually taste better on day two when the flavors have had time to meld together. They also freeze exceptionally well for up to three months, which makes them a great make ahead option for holiday gifting.

• Layer them between sheets of parchment paper in your storage container so they dont stick together.
• Pull them out of the fridge about ten minutes before serving so the chocolate softens slightly and the peanut butter center tastes creamier.
• Always tell people they contain peanuts before serving, because the chocolate coating hides the filling and assumptions can be dangerous.

Save to Pinterest

Every buckeye you dip will look a little different from the last one, and that is part of the charm. They are meant to look homemade and generous and slightly imperfect, exactly the kind of thing you would be proud to hand to someone you love.

Recipe Questions & Answers

→ Why are they called buckeye cookies?

They are named after the buckeye nut from the Ohio buckeye tree. The partially dipped peanut butter ball with exposed filling on top closely resembles the appearance of the nut, which is dark brown with a light tan center.

→ Do buckeye cookies need to be refrigerated?

Yes, it is best to store them in the refrigerator in an airtight container. They will keep well for up to two weeks chilled. The cold temperature also helps the chocolate coating stay firm and the peanut butter filling hold its shape.

→ Can I freeze buckeye cookies?

Absolutely. Place them in a single layer in an airtight container with parchment paper between layers. They can be frozen for up to three months. Thaw them in the refrigerator before serving for the best texture.

→ What type of peanut butter works best?

Standard creamy peanut butter produces the most consistent results. Natural peanut butter can work but may cause the dough to be too soft or oily due to variable oil content. If using natural peanut butter, you may need additional powdered sugar to achieve the right consistency.

→ How do I get a smooth chocolate coating?

Melt the chocolate chips with shortening or coconut oil in 30-second intervals, stirring thoroughly between each interval. The added fat helps create a glossy, fluid coating. Use a toothpick to dip each ball and gently tap off excess chocolate before placing on parchment paper.

→ Can I use dark chocolate instead of semisweet?

Yes, dark chocolate works wonderfully and adds a richer, more intense flavor that pairs beautifully with the sweet peanut butter filling. Use the same amount and melt it with shortening or coconut oil for the best dipping consistency.